Teaching ALL of American History

Michael Streich (Written & Published in 2012)

For teachers of American History, the task of covering all the material from the period of “discovery of the new world” to contemporary events is daunting and nearly impossible. In most cases, the curriculum is dictated by mandated state standards and courses of study that attempt to touch on key events and concepts detailed in 30 to 35 chapters of text.

 

The inclination and temptation to spend more time on favorite eras is checked by performance evaluations that gauge how well state requirements are addressed and how standardized test scores validate those requirements. Innovative strategies, however, might satisfy overall state standards as well as allow a greater degree of classroom freedom in terms of teaching key material.

 

Teaching American History using a Thematic Approach

 

Thematic treatments can still be chronological in order to be effective. For example, a semester theme focusing on expansion can analyze and correlate the following chronological events:

 

Colonial expansion up to the Mississippi

Beginning of the Westward Movement

Manifest Destiny

Expansionism in Foreign Affairs – 19^th Century

Imperialism

Global expansion through the World Wars

Cold War military and economic expansion

 

Other thematic approaches might cover the following areas:

 

The Move toward Democratic Ideals and Civil Rights

Using Court Cases to Teach U.S. History

American Innovations, Industrialism, and the Urban Nation

 

Mini Sections that Focus on Mico Historical Events

 

Another creative and chronological focus develops key or watershed movements in American History as a core focus from which ancillary topics are extrapolated. In this approach, the core focus becomes the center of study as well as the primary learning outcome.

 

If the core focus is “British tax policies after 1763 directly caused the American Independence Movement,” ancillary proofs can be taken from several actual events, determined by their ultimate impact on the core focus:

 

The Stamp Act

The Quartering Act

The Declaratory Act

The Boston Tea Party and subsequent Coercive Acts

Lexington and Concord

 

Rather than spending an inordinate amount of time on the 1763 Proclamation Line, the Townshend Acts, the Boston Massacre, and the Sons of Liberty, more pivotal events tell the story quickly without sacrificing content.

 

Begin American History at 1800

 

In North Carolina, the Revolutionary War and the birth of the nation is part of the sophomore-level civics course, enabling teachers of juniors to begin studies in the 19^th century and thereby have a better opportunity to meet state standards that require covering up to and including the 21^st Century.

 

Inevitably, however, significant problems exist:

 

Juniors have difficulty recalling curricula details from one semester to the next if interrupted by long summer breaks

Transfer students from out-of-state districts may have never been taught the earlier material

Even the best attempts of honest coverage results in “snap-shot” lesson plans that conform to a detailed history text.

 

Teaching American History from Selected Documents

 

This approach has many advantages. Using selected documents still maintains a chronological approach and it introduces students to primary source documents. Original source documents take studying and analysis to a higher level of critical thinking.

 

The singular negative in this approach rests with a teacher or instructor not fluent enough in the discipline to provide background information when needed or to make necessary connections between those documents that highlight similar themes. These points to a teacher enslaved by a publisher’s wrap-around-teacher edition of the text and the endless power point presentations that offer slightly more than a generic treatment of the material.

 

Worst Case Scenario

 

The worst case is usually walking into an American History class in March and finding that the American Civil War has just ended. Students in such classes never hear about World War I and never reach Vietnam under President Johnson. Such situations are found more in non-public schools where state standards are either not applied or vastly tweaked to satisfy the interests of individual teachers.

 

The Call for History Accountability

 

Since 2000, American elections have become more volatile and divisive within society. During the 2008 presidential election, young voters were enticed by Barack Obama’s message of change and voted in great numbers. Voting, however, correlates to knowledge of American History that is at the very least passable.

 

Unless educators develop innovative ways to teach the full gamut of American History in a meaningful way, employing strategies to ensure realistic student outcomes, standardization and “bubble-sheet” exams will continue to demonstrate that many American high school graduates know very little about their own history.

2021

The above reflections are even more important in the current pandemic crisis, which has all but eliminated in-person instruction and subjected most students to the deadening daily impact of "remote" learning. At the same time, those clamoring to remove statues and other public memorabilia resulting in an erasure of American History will damn an entire generation who may never know the truths of the past, good or bad.